Search About Newsletters Donate
Support what you value

Our year-end campaign is happening now, and we have until December 31st to raise $100,000 to fund our journalism into 2027. This work makes a difference. Become a part of it by donating today.

Closing Argument

From Courthouse Arrests to ‘Re-Detentions,’ ICE’s Tactics Test Legal Limits

After a record 491,000 arrests in fiscal year 2026, judges, state officials and advocates are pushing back. House Democrats will investigate in January.

A photo shows a man in a black shirt with his hands cuffed behind his back. A police officer is guiding him forward by his arm. An ICE agent is walking behind them.
Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents make an arrest during an early morning operation in Park Ridge, Illinois, in September 2025.

This is The Marshall Project’s Closing Argument newsletter, a weekly deep dive into a key criminal justice issue. Want this delivered to your inbox? Sign up for future newsletters.

Late last month, an Immigration and Customs Enforcement officer told Ramon Quintero Alvarez he was being released from immigrant detention, even offering the father of two a celebratory fist-bump, Alvarez would later testify.

It had been eight months since he was first detained. Without the aid of a lawyer, he filed a habeas corpus petition and secured an order for his release from the Aurora ICE Processing Center in Colorado. Officials gave Alvarez his belongings, and he walked through the lobby and out into a public area — where, unbeknownst to him, ICE agents were waiting to detain him again.

Department of Justice officials argued in federal court that this brief moment of freedom satisfied U.S. District Court Judge Charlotte Sweeney’s ruling that Alvarez be released, at which point they could arrest him again. A week after the re-arrest, government lawyers told Sweeney that Alvarez was still in custody and that they wouldn’t file a brief defending the new detention. They asked her to close the case on the grounds that ICE had already carried out her original order to release him.

Sweeney declined that request, and on Wednesday, found multiple senior ICE and Trump administration officials in contempt of court, arguing that the practice of re-arresting people like Alvarez made a “mockery of court orders.” She declined to take further action after Denver’s acting-ICE chief testified that he had ordered an end to these “re-detention” efforts, which as of early November, had been used against at least 18 people in Colorado, including Alvarez.

Despite that promise to stop, DHS has defended the practice broadly, saying that a judge’s release order “does not immunize the alien from immigration enforcement for all time,” provided any new arrest complies with the ruling that ordered them released.

Officials in Minnesota, where these kinds of re-arrests have also occurred, have made no such pledge to stop. Judges there have split on whether the practice represents a violation of their release orders.

Re-arrests are one of the ways ICE has been testing the legal limits of who it can take into custody, where, and on what grounds, as it works to deliver on President Donald Trump’s promise of mass deportations. According to agency data, the administration made more than 491,000 immigration arrests in the fiscal year that ended on Sept. 30, the most in ICE’s history.

In Massachusetts, ICE has been making arrests at “sensitive locations” despite the state’s PROTECT Act. Signed into law in August, the act is intended to keep agents away from schools, daycares, healthcare facilities, and courthouses. Nevertheless, CBS Massachusetts reported that between Nov. 3-12, Massachusetts courthouses recorded 22 arrests by ICE.

DHS has said the Supremacy Clause of the Constitution, which sets federal law above state and local statutes, overrides Massachusetts restrictions on courthouse arrests. The text of the PROTECT Act, though, authorizes the state attorney general to seek a court order enforcing the restrictions, setting up a legal fight over how much authority the state has to govern access to its courts. A spokesperson for state Attorney General Andrea Campbell told WGBH that her office was “actively evaluating all available legal options to protect access to our courthouses and hold federal authorities accountable.”

In Virginia, a lawsuit filed Monday alleges that ICE agents have been arresting people without warrants or first establishing that they’re in the country unlawfully and likely to escape before a warrant can be obtained. Six residents and an immigrant rights group accused the agency of targeting people it perceives to be Latino in its drive to meet arrest quotas. Among the plaintiffs is an 18-year-old U.S. citizen who says agents shackled and detained her for hours after she came to retrieve a car following her fiance’s arrest.

The broader immigration crackdown has also reached longtime green-card holders returning from trips abroad. Authorities are detaining some over old offenses that previously hadn’t prevented them from renewing their immigration status or traveling, signaling a shift in the treatment of longtime legal residents who have already undergone government vetting, The Washington Post reported this week.

Take San Juanita Guerra, then 74, who earlier this year spent 22 days in detention after officials at a South Texas border crossing flagged a 1994 misdemeanor for carrying an unloaded pistol into an airport. At the time, she said she’d taken the gun from her teenage child who was struggling with suicidal thoughts and forgotten it was in her purse. After a fine and probation, the gun case was dismissed, and a notary public incorrectly advised her that she didn’t need to disclose it on future applications, she told The Post.

The Post reported that DHS did not respond to questions about how many green-card holders it has detained, and that the agency has said background reviews of noncitizens are essential for safeguarding the country.

ICE’s unprecedented arrest push has also filled rooms meant for brief stays. At the agency’s Miramar office in Florida, civil rights groups allege people have been held for 27 days or longer at a site intended for check-ins and processing. A complaint filed Tuesday alleges agents routinely pressure detainees to sign deportation papers, including one account that officers threatened to withhold access to medications unless people signed voluntary departure forms. Angel Cata, a supervisory detention and deportation officer with ICE, disputed the allegations in a sworn declaration.

Prolonged confinement is also drawing a court challenge at the border, where arrests have fallen to record lows. Legal advocates told a federal court last week that children were spending up to a month in cold, sunless Border Patrol facilities meant to hold them for no more than 72 hours, sometimes locked in a cell for 23 hours a day.

In both cases, immigrant rights groups are turning to courts and federal watchdogs for help.

They may soon have allies with subpoena power. Congressional Democrats are preparing to investigate the administration’s crackdown when they take the majority in January. On Wednesday, Rep. Robert Garcia, the incoming chairman of the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee, told White House Chief of Staff Stephen Miller in a letter to preserve records concerning arrest quotas, enforcement tactics and the treatment of detainees.

“Oversight Democrats have documented 1,165 instances of concerning uses of force, arrests or detentions, deportations, enforcement actions at sensitive locations, and acts of intimidation or retaliation by DHS personnel, and we want answers,” Garcia wrote.

Tags: →Department of Homeland Security →Aurora, Colorado →Miramar, Florida →green card →court order →Re-Detention →Massachusetts →PROTECT Act (Massachusetts) →Colorado →Immigration →Immigration Detention →Second Trump administration →Supremacy Clause →Immigration and Customs Enforcement